Architecture – Gadgets for the rich? – Gautam Bhatia

We talked to Gautam Bhatia about the role and relevance of architects today in the society, particularly India. We asked, ‘Has the profession distanced itself from the people at large? And, if it was only serving the elite?’ His response is following:

Editing and Transcription: Anupriya Saraswat

Architecture Disconnected

Architect Gautam Bhatia eloquently puts it, ‘architects aren’t really needed anymore.’

Architects have really isolated themselves. Our own work cycle has taken us away from city living and we are only capable of designing behind high boundary walls.” He comments, when asked about how Indian urbanscapes are continuously deteriorating, while rural development is carried out with little to no professional intervention – the resultant buildings being climate responsive and highly contextual.

Ar. Bhatia speaks about how contemporary architecture in India evolved as a problem solving technique, eschewing the more abstract ideals of art as one would observe in Europeans countries, and focussing instead on evolving a workable model for urban living in the newly independent nation. This particular approach to architecture, however, was what lent the momentum to post-independence development. As he says, “If you look at the history of architecture since independence, the initial impulse to employing architects was to engage them in a society which was essentially unmade. There was no thought of an urban society in India, after colonialism… In the race of development, we need the architect to perform many miracles. Just like medical miracles, architects were similarly called upon to contribute to the society. I think in the 70s and the 80s there was a much greater understanding of its potential to be a great problem solver.”

With the opening up of the economy and subsequent advent of globalization, this impulse has, however, largely disappeared. What was once a tool for urban expression and social development has now been reduced to a largely dispensable service availed almost exclusively by the rich. Ar. Bhatia talks about how our cities have become increasingly dreary – the dissonance markedly poignant given our rich history of urbanism – and how this beauty is now confined to enclosed enclaves. “In a country which has produced some of the most amazing landscapes and urbanscapes like Jaisalmer…It’s not that we need to go back to that, but the kind of sheer wretchedness of modern urban life is disheartening.”

This particular statement highlights how the disconnect between people and the profession has been largely our doing. Architects have distanced themselves from the larger picture, and what contributes to the spirit of an urban place. Architecture has shifted from an experiential art to a graphic art, with more and more focus on the outward appearance of buildings as a primary objective rather than its evolution as a product of planning. This shift from prioritizing function to prioritizing aesthetics highlights a worrying trend in India – architecture as an advertisement.

Architects are seen as essentially superfluous. They’ve become gadgets for the rich, useful to portray the client’s idea. All that, I think, is in the vein of advertising; a big villa, a big farmhouse, Aamby valley and Lavassa etc – many such places have come up where the essential thought has shifted to the rich who can afford architecture.

And therein lies the root cause of this disconnect. When architecture becomes a tool for advertising, buildings become a cluster of facilities – highlighted by the current trend of Builder-designed buildings, which exclusively develop luxury realty. This tendency neglects a vast chunk of the country’s population, essentially depriving them of availing an important service. “The work in the industry now is work for the really rich or for the really poor, and the middle class is nearly wiped out. The really rich are not interested in architectural ideas. Similarly, building for the poor – it should be a distillation of technology and architectural ideas, but now it’s down to only affordability. I think that’s happening everywhere, and the builders have wiped even the poor off the map.”

This brings up the concept of social conscience – which is missing right from the grassroots level. As a professional community, our focus has turned inwards, towards emulation and isolated expression as opposed to cohesive development linked to contextuality, suitability, and regional identity.  As Ar. Bhatia rightly puts it, “The minute you (as a student) say your concern is with farmhouses for the rich and not housing for the poor, then you’re starting out on the wrong foot. One of the great things about architecture was that it was social; a study of anthropology through buildings. You made buildings because you were a humanist, and because you could understand and mould human behaviour through the built environment. But now it has taken after commercial art, and people who will now become architects are not even taught the basics and will venture straight into 3-d programs and make views.

This is further exacerbated by the fact that architecture is closely tied in with polity, and hence must be essentially rooted in public welfare. But as this social conscience erodes, so does our relevance to the society as a whole. While the recent economic setback has definitely served as an eye-opener – exposing how most luxury realty is ridiculously inflated for vast profit margins, and hence shifting the demand somewhat towards architects, as opposed to builders, again – the fact remains that the first step towards regaining that relevance, and ultimately respect, is through shifting our focus towards designing for the masses, and not let globalization warp the inherent regionalism of the art.

A professional community which cannot cater to the needs – both implicit and explicit – of the populace it stems from, will be ultimately disregarded as redundant. The new crop of architects needs to step out of this self-congratulatory mind-set of perpetuating exclusivity – if not from the spirit of goodwill, then at least for the sake of self-preservation.

Gautam BhatiaGautam Bhatia is an award winning architect and architectural critic, who has authored several books on architecture. His thoughts on architecture and planning are internationally published in news papers and journals.



Books By Gautam Bhatia

Architecture - Gadgets for the rich? - Gautam Bhatia 1   Architecture - Gadgets for the rich? - Gautam Bhatia 3



  1. Jaisim Krishna Rao says

    Love the consistency of Gautam s critical analysis over the decades. With the thoughts all the way

  2. […] Art imitates life, but life also imitates art. What we see relentlessly propagated in popular media subconsciously affects our psyche and our understanding of the craft, the foundation of the experiential art of architecture being eroded by the demand for split-second visual appeal. Mediocre buildings with flashy exteriors have become the norm, blatantly ignorant of their context and aloof from the public. As we discussed with Gautam Bhatia previously, […]

  3. Bilal Khan says

    I am amazed by the fact that this text has nothing fresh to contribute to an already popular opinion. All the low-hanging fruit have been picked. Conveniently ignoring government policies/regulations, politics, architecture education, market forces, new technology and general lack of awareness in everyday public. Decay in the discipline is easily blamed on the students. In my view, they are not creating but facing the problems stated in the piece. I see nothing wrong in wanting to design a farmhouse, or any other architectural object ”for the rich” as long as it involves the right values. And most of the time this is not a position one chooses while studying architecture but when he/she steps out from college into already deteriorating practices. There is no place for aspiring messiahs/saviors of the societies in the society itself. I have witnessed disgruntled urban designers working in interior design studios because in the end everybody has to pay their bills to survive. Portfolios laden with photo-realistic views are critical for young professionals to get internships or jobs. How about discussing the importance of drawings and new methods of representation? This could have been an interesting piece providing insights and inspiration to architecture students and professionals but instead it begins on the pessimistic note of ”architects aren’t really needed anymore”. Architecture intelligentsia need to get off that high horse and engage in dialogues reevaluating and redefining the place of architect in the contemporary Indian society.

    1. Sunandan says


Share your comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More to Explore

Angelica Grace Home, at Tamil Nadu, by Shanmugam Associates

Senior living planned using low cost construction techniques – Angelica Grace Home, at Tamil Nadu, by Shanmugam Associates

With a pristine thought of serving the aged, Clarac Charity Trust approached the architects to develop a senior living. Trichy, a tier-2 city located in the central region of Tamil Nadu in India, is well connected, has affordable cost of living, offers good water yield and is a religious hub; therefore making the city ideal for senior living. Angelic Grace Home is a 30,000-sqft Ground +2 structure that was planned comprising 50 fully furnished rooms. Abundant natural lighting and ventilation, constraints on construction cost and community spaces for the elderly were factors that influenced the design approach. – Shanmugam Associates

Read More »
Central Vista Redevelopment

Central Vista Redevelopment: An Architectural Perspective, by Samvad Design Studio

In a nation regarded as a palimpsest, how does one build? This is the task ahead of architect Bimal Patel and it is against the backdrop of layered history, we analyse the proposal for the Central Vista. While, much of the opinions in public domain about the project revolve around its politics, this article attempts to analyse the proposal as a polemical as well as technical exercise in urban design and architecture – where the program, site, client, budget and time-lines prescribed are regarded as a given. The reading of the proposal reveals a conciliatory approach at the urban level, post-ideological position at the architectural level and literal treatment of the interiors. – Samvad Design Studio

Read More »
Professor Anand Swarup Arya, an Earthquake Engineer for the poor and the non-engineered

Professor Anand Swarup Arya, an Earthquake Engineer for the poor and the non-engineered

Professor Anand Swarup Arya, Padma Shri (2002), United Nations Sasakawa Disaster Prevention Award (1997) was a rare professor, academic administrator, scholar and mentor. His passing away after a singular life of service to the engineering and architecture community of India and the world perhaps did not get the attention it deserved. These two tributes by two of his students, both highly reputed Structural Engineers will hopefully help convey Professor Arya’s life and work to the larger architecture and construction community.

Read More »
Rajasthan State Archives Museum, Bikaner, by Dronah

Rajasthan State Archives Museum, Bikaner, by Dronah

The recently completed Rajasthan State Archives Museum at Bikaner, by Dronah, is an invaluable resource for the nation. It is one of the first archives’ museums in India that sets a benchmark for other State Archives Department in the country as to how invaluable historic documents and old land records can be transferred from dust-laden stores to be conserved and showcased in a publicly engaging and state of the art designed museum.

Read More »
Topsy Tury at Nagpur by Zeel Architects

Topsy-Turvy at Nagpur, by Zeel Architects

Situated on a small plot of 16.0 x 30.20 mts. And having an even smaller usable floor plate of about 13.20 x 21.60 Mts., the Topsy Turvy by Zeel Architects, building stands out from the neighbourhood, due to the geometric envelope holding jalis in it.

Read More »