“Deception by Design..” – Dwaipayan Chakravarty on Photoshopped Architecture

Share Post:

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email

When I was contacted by ArchitectureLive! to weigh in on ‘Photoshopped Architecture’ – a term coined by them – I admit, my interest was piqued.

As an architect, my own relationship with visual media has been the very crux of my medium of communication with my clients. I’ve used a variety of tools and methods to ‘best bring out’ the vital aspects of my conception, including image editing tools, 3D rendering tools and whatnot.

The hypothesis brought about by the introductory article seemed intrinsically harsh to me – that the professional community (that includes me) dabbles in the falsification of architecture’s representation, at the cost of the actual sanctity of the architectural experience. Quite the travesty, that! Have we, as a profession, succumbed to such heresy? That our Architecture is all about the Kardashian-ification of its external envelope, as we post it on magazines and social media for the gleeful gratification of our clients and peers?! Architecture with a selfish ‘pout’?!

Photoshopped Architecture

As the thought churned in my head, I realized that the discussion has a precursor, and the actual point of discussion is not so much about the photoshopping of our renders to hide a design flaw, but the very question of Truthfulness and Design!

Architecture has always followed various means to an end, and each of us has prioritized differently to achieve them. For some, it is Sustainability above all else, for some the Human Experience, for others, perhaps, cost, while some may even revel in the maximizing of his/her clients profits through design. There is no good or bad here, no such shades of black and white, as long as the priority and the aim are clear.

But what really is the intent of our Architecture? What does the good Architect primarily try to do, what the others simply can’t? For intent, I believe, architecture is meant to inspire happiness, the pursuit of which is intrinsic to many other intents of life. This happiness is a sort of behavioural change that our architecture is expected to catalyze in our buildings’ users.

Happiness in architecture is brought about by many things, and it inherently is achieved in myriad ways – through the joy of surprise, though the comfort of scale, through the wonder of beauty, through the impeccability of precise construction detailing, through the building of bonhomie and community, and the humility of building with nature. In such a pursuit, we abstract our own thoughts to materialize an architecture that ‘priority combines’ the many complexities of built-form and the flawed intricacies of humans.

Whether we like it or not, in such abstractions and representations, we do deviate from the truth in many ways. We hide infrastructural pipelines to showcase the simplicity of surfaces, we clad our exteriors to bring effect of wonder, we over-glaze our buildings to make a statement, and we add vegetative ‘greening’ to make a valid point about sustainability. 

Do we really, and I mean REALLY travel the truthful path in such mechanisms of complex design? I find such truth only in simple, traditional village homes. But we no longer just deal in such simplicity, do we now? Whenever we accentuate, we deviate from the optimum, and whenever we showcase, we abstract the aesthetics to a discernible form. There is a scale of deviation here which we must be careful and accountable of, where the barrage of so-called white lies becomes a wholesome untruth.

All in all, I feel – being the Devil’s advocate here – that an acceptable element of hiding or masking or accentuation to get the intent across to the end-user is more important than a conscious effort for truthful architecture. I feel images have to look good – heck, they need to look great! And before the architecture of the building is actually constructed, they form the basis of inspiration to actually emulate.

I have nothing really against ‘photoshopping’ our architecture as you will. But it needs to be within the intangible realm of acceptability. If the photoshopping tells the ultimate story and achieves the intent of inspiring joy and better appreciation, maybe it’s good?!

Truthfulness in Architecture? Nah… I call it Deception by Design.

"Deception by Design.." - Dwaipayan Chakravarty on Photoshopped Architecture 3

Dwaipayan Chakravarty is an Architect and Urban Designer settled in Pune. He has had the opportunity to work with some leading firms and enjoys writing on such subjects close to his heart, and doesn’t mind being the fox in the chicken coop when it comes to expressing his thoughts. He enjoys being close to Architectural academics when he can, and has great hope for the future of Architecture in India.

One Reply to ““Deception by Design..” – Dwaipayan Chakravarty on Photoshopped Architecture”

Share your comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You May Also Like

Earth House, at Kanakapura, Bangalore, India, by Svamitva Architecture Studio

Earth House, at Kanakapura, Bangalore, India, by Svamitva Architecture Studio

Situated in a 28 acre site, the Terravana also called the Earth house is a design intervention that travels along the lines of earth and sustainability. In a plot size of 34.4×60 ft the unit focuses on a minimum footprint integrated with greenery. The interior setting transcends with the Pairing of age old technique of lime plastering with mid-century themed furniture. With delicately chosen décor that complements the theme of wellness and the colour palette of natural tones exhibits strength, sound and health. – Svamitva Architecture Studio

Read More »
Studio Emerald

Happy Head, at Hyderabad, by Studio Emerald

Tucked into the affluent neighborhood of Film Nagar – Hyderabad, Happy Head is a wellness destination that prides itself on being the primary and sole branch of its kind in the Indian context. The country’s first I.V. Clinic, this venue is a collaborative alliance amidst its founder who has a celebrated presence in the hospitality genre and the team at Studio Emerald. 

Read More »
LOUVERED HOUSE, at Bangalore, by White Shadows Design Studio

LOUVERED HOUSE, at Bangalore, by White Shadows Design Studio

The house was designed for a textile businessman from Rajasthan whose family spans three generations. The design brief consisted of three luxurious bedrooms, ample living spaces, entertainment and service areas.

The 30’X40’ site located in a growing residential area and flanked by dense multi dwellings on three sides, has a road to the West thus creating a design challenge.- White Shadows Design Studio

Read More »
Cinema Multiplex | 6 Screens, at Pacific D21 Mall | Dwarka | New Delhi, by ivpartners

Cinema Multiplex | 6 Screens, at Pacific D21 Mall | Dwarka | New Delhi, by ivpartners

The capital’s new sub-city of Dwarka is coming as the next international diplomatic hub. Brimming with new developments and destination retail experiences it is being developed under the Smart City project. Located on the Metro interchange station this mall is home to a six-screen mega multiplex. Circumscribing a large atrium, the cinema is fronted by retail & flanked by a generous food court. Here, the design narrative needed an elegant new approach speaking a vibrant modernist language in luxury entertainment. – ivpartners

Read More »

Subscribe to Architecture and Design Updates