On purism and posterity – discussing Photoshopped Architecture – Shruti Hemani

Shruti Hemani

Shruti Hemani

Share Post:

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email

We carry forth our discussion about ‘Photoshopped Architecture’ and attempt to navigate the distinction between artistic liberty and representational integrity – at the intersection of which architectural photography currently lies. Does the beauty of the shot trump the reality of the building? Or is this inherent mistrust of the medium the real problem?

We invited the opinions of Tanya Khanna, the founder of Epistle Communications, and Shruti Hemani, Associate Professor at Aayojan School of Architecture, to reconcile the academic as well as commercial aspects of this issue. 

When asked about the ideal medium for portrayal of buildings, Khanna tells us, “Drawings, Text and Infographics – all of these tell a story together to communicate design ideas. She brings to this discussion her valuable insight about how architectural projects can – and should – be represented, and talks about how relying on photography alone can be problematic, “Scale often gets completely distorted in photographs, and the sense of place is often never conveyed due to photographic limitations. Also, photographing a building before it is inhabited, without any people in the shot, is quite misleading – and renders the space as purist, rather than rooted in reality.

Photoshopped Architecture
No people or sense of place – a purist photographic vision reduces the building to a mere visual (Pictured – Bacardi Administration Building, Cuba designed by Mies Van Der Rohe; Source: Balthazar Korab)

It’s a point worth pondering – especially given how modern media and architectural magazines are increasingly publishing images that make these buildings look untouched, almost pristine – often lacking (or perhaps purposefully leaving out) their socio-cultural context. These solemn monoliths jutting out of perfect landscapes do not exist in the real world, where each building grows and evolves with its users, and is in constant interplay with other buildings in the vicinity.

Buildings do not exist in isolation, and their imagery shouldn’t either.

She expounds upon her stance and addresses all forms of post-shoot touch-ups, distinguishing between visual emphasis and clear deception, “Manipulation to distort scale, design and intent is unacceptable. However, manipulation to highlight focal areas or details – for example, a portion rendered in colour as a highlight in an otherwise black and white photograph – adds value to the perception and interpretation of the image.” It is an excellent argument in favour of ‘Photoshopping’ – after all, any and every digital adjustment will be branded with the same label, and it is imperative we distinguish between what can be deemed ethically unacceptable, and what is a mere tool to attract attention.

Shruti Hemani, however, has a more liberal stance – one that skews in favour of artistic expression and individual choices. “Architectural Photography (i.e. visuals of built environment after it has been built) can be open to photographic experiments, unusual experiences and play”, she says, maintaining that the vision of the photographer is just as important a factor in depiction of architecture, especially given the case of ‘passive manipulation’, which involves staging and deliberate perspectives and are as much of a medium of self-expression as they are a method of reporting.

On the other hand, I will argue that post-construction Architectural Photography (i.e. visuals of built environment before it has been built) has a more responsible role to play and promises to live up to.” She adds, delineating the difference in the role and responsibilities of captured images and computer-generated visuals, especially given how the latter is used almost exclusively for marketing purposes, “In this context, I will agree that ‘photo-wash’ might be misleading.

Photoshopped Architecture
Popular architectural imagery sets the tone for future norms of design, as seen in the case of Hadid’s parametricism (Pictured – Hayder Aliyev Centre, Azerbaijan designed by Zaha Hadid; Source: Co.Design)

Having said that, the former too has a certain degree of responsibility in putting forth the role and relevance of architecture in the society,” Hemani tells us, taking the issue from its limited scope of portrayal of buildings to the larger impact of such imagery on contemporary design trends and relevant discourse, “by portraying what is desirable and what is not, the imagery would then dictate what eventually becomes an accepted norm of architectural aesthetics.” Life imitates art, indeed.

This shift from drawings to photographs often represents an approach that is driven purely by a visual aesthetic – it is not an ideal situation,” concludes Khanna, commenting upon what this shift of preference indicates for the profession, and the society as a whole, “Theory, academic concepts and deep-rooted thought is often lost in this translation; and of course, it also means a shift from the technicality of architecture – the process and the putting together of a building – to its reduction to a mere visual.


Text, views curated by: Anupriya Saraswat

Anupriya Sarawat

Anupriya Saraswat is a content editor for Architecture Live! who recently graduated from Aayojan School of Architecture, Jaipur. She has a penchant for writing and research, and seeks to combine curricular learning with contextual pragmatism to deconstruct, interpret – and ultimately – contribute to contemporary architectural discourse.

One Reply to “On purism and posterity – discussing Photoshopped Architecture – Shruti Hemani”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You May Also Like

Framed House, at Bangalore, India, by Crest Architects

Framed House, at Bangalore, India, by Crest Architects

Located within a gated community in North Bangalore, the square-shaped plot of this residence abuts the road on the southern and western sides and enjoys views of the encompassing greenery. Based on the client’s requirements, our approach was to design a modest house with a specific emphasis on natural light and ventilation.  

Read More »

TIGER TIGER – Nisha Mathew Ghosh

TIGER TIGER is part of a series on animals and their implied symbolic narrative appropriated politically and socially. This series studies the perception of people and conjures up new imaginaries as form is divested of its power by dematerializing it via the act of weaving a narrative shorn of the power, panache, swagger associated with the cultural, symbolic or naturalized form. – Nisha Mathew Ghosh

Read More »
Conserving The Commissariat Bulding, DR DN Road, by Vikas Dilawari

Conserving The Commissariat Building, DR DN Road, by Vikas Dilawari

Mumbai was the first city in India to have heritage regulations to protect its living heritage. This listing and the corresponding regulations binding these precincts would also protect these old areas from burdening the fragile infrastructure with high-rise buildings. These precincts, more than individual structures, puts forward each city’s uniqueness. Heritage awareness is certainly increasing on paper with more nominations of World Heritage Site ensembles. But in reality, its protection on the ground is decreasing at an alarming rate.

Read More »

“A Sense of Space: This book is an invitation to liberate oneself from the valorised image of western or imperial city planning towards a more nuanced, indigenous, and flexible approach to our cities.” Sudipto Ghosh Reviews A Sense of Space, by Ranjit Sabikhi

Those wondering why the design of contemporary Indian cities is such an arduous and joyless affair will find Ranjit Sabikhi’s book of immense interest. Many may even find themselves jolted to action within their spheres of influence despite the book’s unflappable tone. Most importantly, this book is an invitation to liberate oneself from the valorised image of western or imperial city planning towards a more nuanced, indigenous, and flexible approach to our cities. – Sudipto Ghosh

Read More »

Highway Restaurants Concept, at New Delhi, by Parag Singal Architects

The stirring proposal of Highway Bridge Restaurant was conceptualized by Parag Singal Architects. The idea is to build restaurants over National Highways that can be accessed from both sides of the road. Located on the center of the highway, it is almost impossible for the restaurant to go unnoticed by the motorists. It offers more visibility to the restaurant and makes it easier for the traveler to spot a place for refreshment, hence creating a win-win situation. – Parag Singal Architects

Read More »
MA001, at Ayroor, Kerala, India, by mamama

MA001, at Ayroor, Kerala, India, by mamama

Located in Ayroor, Kerala this family home that sits on the banks of the Chalakudy river is nothing less than a mini-ecosystem within itself — self-sufficient and symbiotic. Using local masons, carpenters, contractors and construction methods, this home was completed with natural materials such as terracotta and laterite tiles, kota stone and terracotta jaali blocks. A generous verandah wraps around three sides and a large open terrace on the upper floor maximises the spectacular views out onto the river. The house is an extension of the clients’ (perfect) idea of living a retired life.

Read More »

Subscribe to Architecture and Design Updates