“Dream and Reality” the Architecture of Hassan Fathy A story by Design Dalda

design dalda

design dalda

Design Dalda visits the architecture of Hassan Fathy and shares his version of the story.

Share Post:

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email

New Gourna, the name had remained ingrained deep inside me, sensual forms of mud brick domes; an architecture of the people; for the people; by the people and by Architect Hassan Fathy. Much before Fathy reached international stardom through his seminal book, “Architecture for the Poor” he was brought in to help plan ‘New Gourna’. Why and how Fathy landed the commission is not clear, however Fathy, born in 1900, with his deep empathy for the land, its people, clearly was known well enough to have been invited for this prestigious commission.

Mosque by Hassan Fathy at New Gourna Village
The Mosque by Hassan Fathy: © Design Dalda

In this project dated to the 1940’s, the Egyptian government wanted to shift the village Gournii. Gournii at this epoch was a large village that had grown around and over a rich archeological site, in Upper Egypt near Luxor, involved in clandestine tunneling to philander ancient artefacts. For this reason the Government wanted to shift Gournii to New Gourna

I am travelling with a group of journo’s, on a journalistic assignment of sorts through Egypt. I leaf through the heavy Lonely Planet I am carrying and find a little box on Fathy and New Gourna. I wasn’t expecting that we would actually be this close to New Gourna. Tourist folks don’t die for a poor mud-brick village especially when compared to the magnificence of Hatsheput and other similar. I meekly put the idea forward to my co-travellers and to my pleasant surprise they only exhibit much enthusiasm, journalistic enthusiasm! I ask our guide whether he knows Hassan Fathy, “Ofcourse!” he responds, a bit offended, he cautions me that much has changed.

We decide to do it 1st thing in the morning, we swing into narrow lanes of New Gourna, multi-storied houses built like Lego gone slightly awry, this is like in any urbanised Indian villages I tell myself. Just as I am losing hope, a beautiful mosque that retains all the original traits comes into view. We park and enter, huge airy mud domes, arches and courtyards charmed by fiery red bougainvillea, a woven red carpet adds to the ambience. With its serenity, simplicity and wonderful sense of space this mosque feels close to the spirit of Hassan Fathy. We thank the caretaker and step out.

The Market at New Gorna Village ©Design Dalda

The village is mostly in abandon and part ruins, on the left there is one original Fathy house that proudly displays a sign board saying ‘First House to be built in 1946’, which while being lived in has been turned into a museum and study centre. A grand man in keffiyeh with a gentle smile welcomes us, his daughter, also a tourist guide shows us around. Her grandfather was a master mason and Fathy’s righthand man and this house is their tribute to that legacy. One room serves as a library with books by and on Fathy neatly placed on a central table lit by skylights, another yard has shovels, trowels and other construction material which they use to carry out workshops and there is a small reading cum café space. Students of mud architecture from all over the world and all ages come here in small numbers to learn and help maintain and rebuild whatever remains. It is a small effort but very elegant and moving.

We step out, kids engaged in an intense football match on the road side get distracted and pose for photos, but they soon lose interest in this unusual band of tourists and the beautiful game takes over.

A project to kick start the restoration of New Gourna, (which though located within the UNESCO World Heritage Site of Ancient Thebes was not included in the nomination), took off in 2009 only to be stalled in 2011 mainly due to the uncertain political situation. We meet the Governor of Luxor later in the evening, hanging around with journalists has its advantages and we are requested to share any suggestions. I raise my concern, telling him that New Gourna is an international pilgrimage site of the same stature as the works of Corbusier or Frank Lloyd Wright and with some effort could become a revenue generating asset. He is aware of its importance and is hoping that a partnership with UNESCO and others works out, some money has already been allocated, but more is needed, he tells us with certain sincerity.

People for whom the village was built did not really move in and with time as their needs and aspirations changed, even the few that moved in modified and even broke down the homes to rebuild. Why New Gourna wasn’t really occupied, isn’t very clear to me, the original site of Gournii continues to be occupied even today. There is at least one paper that discusses this comparing Fathy’s failed ‘New Gourna’ to another recent proposal, that too the research paper predicted is likely to fail, for the same reason, that of the approach being too top down. It seems what was Fathy’s dream for Gournii, wasn’t the dream of the people for whom it was designed.

You can read more on UNESCO Website.
(Fathy is also credited for the revival of the ancient Nubian vault construction techniques. These vaults standing in the Nubian desert for over 3000 years used a woodless construction technique, a bit like building a vault in thin air, without the slightest need of supporting formwork, but that story for another day)

Share your comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You May Also Like

Administrative Building, at Erode, Tamilnadu, by The Bhargav Group

Unbuilt: Administrative Building, at Erode, Tamilnadu, by The Bhargav Group

The Admin Block is treated in such a way green fields and lush pastures interact with the building add beauty to its environment and a serene entry to the Campus away from the hustle and bustle of main road. The building plinth area covers 6,675 square feet from Site area of 7,782 Square feet. Building area is divided 40% area of mezzanine floor with soil land fill and 60% area of other floor area, with double height space grand lobby enclosed with courtyard space treated with wooden Pergola at the top helps natural light enter into the space. – The Bhargav Group

Read More »
Residential Bungalow, at Raipur, Chhattisgarh, by Azure Interiors

Residential Bungalow, at Raipur, Chhattisgarh, by Azure Interiors

This reimagined family bungalow in Raipur, Chhattisgarh boasts of an elegant ambience that celebrates simple nuances with rich textures and beautiful finishes. Designed by the young and inspiring designer duo Ruchi Gehani and Rashi Bothra of Raipur-based Azure Interiors, the home is a testament to their design acumen and a penchant for bringing balance and vitality to a space through an amalgamation of colour, texture, and materiality. – Azure Interiors

Read More »
The Atrium Project, at Pune, Maharashtra, by OHA STUDIOS

The Atrium Project, at Pune, Maharashtra, by OHA STUDIOS

We were approached by the developers of this mixed-use project to design the interiors of a commercial atrium, residential lobbies and common spaces. The developers were quite keen on exploring something that was different from the traditional atrium designs.

This 2500sqft Atrium – a double-height space in the commercial complex, was the blank canvas that we were to design for. As the entire volume was very rigid and orthogonal with shops at the entry level & offices at the first level, our design concept was to soften this rigidity. Accordingly, we introduced fluid forms into this bounding box. – OHA STUDIOS

Read More »
All That Jazz, at New Delhi, by Mantra One

All That Jazz, at New Delhi, by Mantra One

Mantra One is a leading luxury lifestyle company that has been offering bespoke furniture since 2011. The 10 year old design-house has launched a new line of luxury collection that celebrates unexpected colours and unique material combinations, Mantra One stretches the boundaries of art, engineering and design to create exquisite contemporary furniture. From conceptualization to installation, the company goes the extra mile by offering design consultancy and crafting custom made products to make ‘dream homes’. The collection offers from designer sofas to an array of luxury beds, bars, tables and more.  

Read More »
APDS salon at New Delhi by RLDA STUDIO Architects

APDS salon, at New Delhi, by RLDA STUDIO Architects

The ten thousand square foot beauty salon is a combination of mezzanine spaces (used for speciality treatments and offices) and double height purpose-built cabins interspersed with a series of glass planes with graphic motifs. These elements, individually varied and collectively orchestrated define spaces that provide for the varying degrees of privacy needed in a beauty salon. – RLDA STUDIO

Read More »
In Nature // Sanvina in the Sun!, at Mechkarwadi, near Karjat, Maharashtra, India, by Cluster One Creative Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

In Nature // Sanvina in the Sun!, at Mechkarwadi, near Karjat, Maharashtra, India, by Cluster One Creative Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

We believe that, as architects and designers, our role is exceptionally interim in nature. And by “in nature”, we mean both, the inherent characteristic of a person, as well as the collective physical world around us. After all, for all the glorification we grant to ourselves, we are, eventually, only a means to an end which will exist long after we are gone. Fully aware, and accepting of this interplay of the past, present, and future, we have come to understand that everything we do, is going to interact differently with the evolving sensibilities of the people, the landscape, and the weather, at that point of time, on that given day. – Cluster One Creative Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

Read More »

Subscribe to Architecture and Design Updates